Bobbi, you know I love you girl, but you let me down with your Everything mascara! You said it lengthens, thickens and defines; I did not see one iota of thickening. That tiny bit of lengthening I saw? I’m attributing that to the fact that the tips of my lashes are light and had been darkened by the mascara. Definition? I guess so, but short skinny defined lashes isn’t what I’m after.

The brush is jumbo-sized, a la Dior Show, but I find oversized brushes too difficult to wield on the lower lashes.

I will admit that I sport 3 coats, at a minimum, of mascara at any given time, and I love dramatic lashes. With this mascara, my lashes looked virtually the same except tinted. If you’re looking for a very subdued, clean-looking mascara, this might work for you, but if you’re all about in-your-face lashes, this mascara doesn’t deliver.